Antecedent
This article is written based on the personal classical music evaluation criteria I derived myself, so please check the previous post first.
Reverse Engineering My Personal Classical Music PreferenceIt is a highly subjective evaluation and entirely a matter of taste.
Emergence
The first piece I am sharing my personal thoughts on is Alkan's "30 ans" sonata. Serving as the second movement (Quasi-Faust) of Alkan's Grande Sonate 'Les Quatre Âges', this work is a notoriously difficult masterpiece of the Romantic era. It portrays the intense agony of a person in their 30s by drawing parallels to the Faust legend, expressed through extreme piano technique and an overwhelming scale. I am starting with this piece not because it is my absolute favorite, but because listening to it provoked a lot of my own thoughts.
Stabilization
I will explain things based on the measure numbers, so I recommend reading along with the score. If that is difficult, I have also included timestamps [00:00] based on Marc-André Hamelin's piano performance video in the link below for your reference.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s9RthqXGZmU&list=RDs9RthqXGZmU&start_radio=1
1.Inevitability
If there is a prominent weakness in this movement, it lies in its inevitability. The melodic progression occasionally lacks organic development, resulting in moments that feel abrupt rather than naturally propelled. It is not that sudden tempo changes are inherently bad, but they must feel justified within the broader narrative.
For instance, the simple ascending and descending scale motif starting at measure 10 [0:23] emerges without a clear logical connection to the preceding introduction. Later, at measure 277 [7:16], a specific arpeggio pattern is repeated four times. Rather than building musical tension, this repetition feels somewhat mechanical and awkward to the ear, coming across as a mere technical display rather than a necessary step in the piece's structural flow.
- Catharsis or Sentimentality
- Complexity
According to my criteria, a piece only needs to strongly satisfy one of these two aspects. In the case of "Quasi-Faust," it leans entirely toward catharsis rather than sentimentality.
The piece does contain a few lyrical passages, but the relatively monotonous melodic lines do not evoke vivid emotional imagery or a deep sense of poetic sentimentality. However, where it lacks in delicate emotion, it completely compensates with sheer scale. Through dramatic dynamic control and massive vertical chord progressions, Alkan successfully constructs an overwhelming sense of grandeur. The climactic moments—such as the massive, homophonic weight felt around measure 136 [4:38]—deliver a powerful, undeniable catharsis that physically resonates with the listener. It is slightly disappointing that it relies merely on a repetition of chords.
The complexity of this movement is its most captivating feature and aligns perfectly with the theme of "30 years old." Alkan takes a single musical idea and subjects it to extensive thematic variation. It is easy to infer that the composer envisioned the 30s as a period of intellectual maturity and complex, multidimensional thinking.
The absolute highlight of the entire piece is the massive fugue that begins at measure 231 [7:36]. This dense, polyphonic section makes the overall structure incredibly colorful and intellectually satisfying. It is a brilliant display of contrapuntal writing that elevates the entire movement.
My only minor critique regarding complexity lies in the structural transition that follows. After gradually building immense tension through the complex fugue, the texture suddenly collapses into a sequence of repetitive block chords starting at measure 259 [8:40]. A smoother, more integrated structural build-up to release that accumulated tension would have made the climax feel even more coherent.
One Line Conclusion: While structurally complex and multifaceted, the individual colors themselves lack vitality and remain one-dimensional.
Convergence
Ultimately, this piece is not really to my taste. I only seek it out occasionally when I am in the mood for highly virtuosic pieces, or I just listen to the later fugue section that I actually like. Next time, I will find another piece that provokes my thoughts and share another strictly personal review.
Descendant
The following links lead to my thoughts on other pieces.
From My Personal Criteria… Alkan’s Grande Sonate 'Les Quatre Âges' | |
|---|---|
Lepton | |
Tachyon | |
Gluon | |
Tachyon | |
Phonon | |
Phonon | |
Tachyon | |
Phonon | |
Gluon | |
Tachyon | |
Phonon | |
Lepton | |